Direct-to-consumer brands evaluating performance and retention agencies
eCommerce marketing for New York City metro brands
Two ad platforms claim the same first order. A repeat buyer uses a new email. A Manhattan pickup avoids a shipping cost that a New Jersey delivery incurs. Before you scale a campaign, build one view of what your own checkout earned.
What did a new customer cost?
| Illustrative campaign figures | Amount |
|---|---|
| Acquisition spend | $1,440 |
| Orders claimed across platforms | 31 |
| Verified first-time buyers | 24 |
$60 per verified new buyer. Use actual order contribution and later returns to decide whether that cost works.
Give finance and paid media the same order ledger.
Start with orders your checkout marked paid. Identify first-time customers under your store’s customer rules. Reconcile duplicate ad claims using order IDs. Keep refunds, cancelled orders and local pickup visible. A Manhattan pickup and a parcel shipped to Newark or Jersey City can earn different contributions on the same selling price.
In an illustrative campaign, platforms claim 31 new-customer sales. Your store verifies 24 unique first-time buyers in the campaign group. At $1,440 in acquisition spend, each verified buyer cost $60. Finance compares that with the contribution available per buyer before deciding what the paid team should spend next.
Did the retention campaign create additional orders?
For a worked example, randomly split eligible repeat customers into equal groups. Send the new retention campaign to one group. Both continue to receive their usual messages. With the same observation window, eight additional orders at $18 contribution each leave $144 before the extra campaign cost.
After a $40 test-only cost, the observed difference is $104. A small test is a reason to repeat the comparison over more customers and settled returns before increasing acquisition spend.
| Measure | New campaign | Usual messages |
|---|---|---|
| Eligible customers | 400 | 400 |
| Orders | 36 | 28 |
| Order contribution before campaign cost | $648 | $504 |
| Contribution after extra campaign cost | $608 | $504 |
Your four-step growth planner
Review one offer’s order economics
Use the growth planner to estimate the work, or book a meeting to review a closed order period. Bring aggregate first orders, refunded sales, variable costs and acquisition spend.
